BERWICK STAR NEWS
Home » No mosque poll

No mosque poll

CASEY councillors have rejected a move to poll residents regarding a controversial planning application for a mosque which was passed last week.
Cr Rosalie Crestani urged the council at a meeting on Tuesday night to ask Doveton residents their opinions about council’s decision to grant a permit made by Achivision for the use and development of a mosque at 27, 29 and 31 Green Street, Doveton despite strong opposition.
The council received four objecting petitions which included over 2000 signatures.
Pastor Daniel Nalliah and members from Catch the Fires ministries voiced strong opposition to the mosque, as they plan to build a new church on neighbouring land.
The move to approve the mosque was made by Cr Wayne Smith following the recommendations of council officers.
He said many of the objectors were non-residents and about 1900 signatures on one petition did not leave their address, raising questions as to its validity.
Cr Crestani said it was important to seek the ”voice of the people” and changed her motion from polling all of Casey residents to only Doveton residents to reduce the cost from about $327,000 to $12,000, estimated by the Victorian Electorial Commission.
Cr Wayne Smith slammed the move, saying it was “ludicrous” to pay ratepayers’ money to get an opinion from the public on a decision which was already made.
“It’s now out of our hands and (a poll) is not going to make a difference,” he said.
Cr Stapledon questioned what Cr Crestani hoped to achieve through the poll.
“We could be more knowledgeable and we could set a precedent to do it before future controversial decisions,” Cr Crestani said.
Cr Smith said it could set a “dangerous precedent” as any councillor could request a poll be taken after they were not happy with a council decision.
“It’s mischief-making,” he said.
Cr Sam Aziz supported the motion, while Crs Smith, Stapledon, Mick Morland, Susan Serey, Geoff Ablett, and Louise Berkelmans voted against it. Cr Damien Rosairio and Cr Gary Rowe were not at the meeting.
Cr Crestani then moved that council seek a report on the viability of conducting a poll, which Cr Aziz supported and the other councillors present voted against.

Digital Editions


More News

  • Home batteries boom in the outer Melbourne suburbs

    Home batteries boom in the outer Melbourne suburbs

    More than 250,000 households, small businesses and community organisations have installed home batteries — with the majority of them subsiding in the outer suburbs of Victoria. The top postcodes for…

  • Bandits fall as Roos hop

    Bandits fall as Roos hop

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 537219 Parkfield has been on top of the DDCA Turf 2 ladder for a long time but Coomoora will now head into finals in…

  • Hope is enough for Bucks

    Hope is enough for Bucks

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 527654 Much like the Dandenong District Cricket Association’s (DDCA) Turf 1 competition, Springvale South and Buckley Ridges will battle it out this weekend at…

  • Champs make move in highlight performance of round four

    Champs make move in highlight performance of round four

    Defending champion High 5’s has once again put its stamp on Division 1 of the Mountain Dart League after an impressive 8-2 victory in the top-of-the-table clash against Bullseyes. Both…

  • Cross realises AFL dream as Demons pick up Casey product

    Cross realises AFL dream as Demons pick up Casey product

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 499252 Consistency, persistence and belief. Those three words have defined Paddy Cross’ journey to the top level after the livewire utility was officially picked…

  • Dasun earns recognition

    Dasun earns recognition

    Dasun Opanayaka couldn’t have had a better debut season in the DDCA after moving to Springvale South and recently being crowned the 2025/26 Wookey Medallist. Actually … there is one…

  • Bears and Bucks win big

    Bears and Bucks win big

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 537218 The first week of finals is now set for the Dandenong District Cricket Association (DDCA) Turf 1 competition with two enticing match-ups set…

  • Noble Park locked and loaded

    Noble Park locked and loaded

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 520678 Noble Park (7/121) can begin preparations for a finals campaign in the Victorian Sub-District Cricket Association after locking down a top-six berth with…

  • Sweet taste for battling teams as things even up in SWGDL

    Sweet taste for battling teams as things even up in SWGDL

    Three teams enjoyed their first wins of the season in round three of the South West Gippsland Dart League (SWGDL) while the top-four cemented their claims as early premiership contenders.…

  • Car ramming leads to firearm seized in Cranbourne East

    Car ramming leads to firearm seized in Cranbourne East

    A man has been charged following an incident at a property in Cranbourne East where a Toyota SUV allegedly rammed a Ford off Collision Road about 2.30pm on Saturday 28…